Comfortably Numb: The Inside Story of Pink Floyd

Mark Blake


(Da Capo)

 

www.dacapopress.com

 

Mark Blake has clearly done his share of research, checking in with everyone who ever got within a quarter-mile of Pink Floyd's inner circle, it would seem. And yet, it's not until he's kicked off Chapter Three with "What a rave! A man crawling naked through jelly. Girls stripped to the waist. Offbeat poetry. Weird music..." that he's pieced those notes together in a way that makes you want to turn the page and find out more.

 

Setting the stage at the Live 8 reunion is an interesting enough device, but the details may have resonated more at the end of the book, once the character flaws of the individual members of the band have been brought sharply into focus (although Roger Waters' standing as the royal bastard of the group is clear from page one). And a flair for overstatement doesn't help. "Just when it seems as if rock music has long lost its power to offend," the book begins, "Pink Floyd's reunion has thrown the establishment into a panic."

 

 

Chapter Two: "The Endless Summer" reads more like "The Endless Chapter." This one picks up a year after Live 8 with the news that Syd Barrett has died. From there, you get a chapter on their parting ways in 1968, with David Gilmour coming in to take his place; a chapter on Barrett refusing to answer the door when a journalist shows up looking for a quote a week before the Live 8 concert and some insights into Barrett's final years before he takes you back to the beginning of the story.

 

 

And that's when it really starts creeping along. The trouble is that Blake has worked in way too many minor characters to give their quotes the proper context. And flitting around between Barrett and Gilmour and Waters and all these minor players doesn't help. Just when you think you've got a feel for someone's childhood, he's already on to someone else's.

 

 

Once you hit the Marquee Club in 1966, though, with the Pink Floyd Sound appearing at the "Spontaneous Underground Happening," it's like a different book. Blake paints an often fascinating portrait of the London Underground and Pink Floyd's standing at the center of that scene.

 

 

It isn't long, of course, before the drugs that helped make Piper at the Gates of Dawn their first and -- some would argue -- most enduring masterpiece destroyed the main creative force behind that album. Syd Barrett's descent into madness is covered in heartbreaking detail, as is Waters' emergence as the Alpha Male whose obsession with running the show results in several classic albums (Dark Side of the Moon, Wish You Were Here, The Wall) while making Let It Be feel like A Hard Day's Night.

 

 

There's not much happiness to go around in Blake's account of Pink Floyd's post-Barrett career. There's a sense of accomplishment. And pride. And maybe even satisfaction. But there's no real joy. As tension mounts between Gilmour and Waters, keyboard player Richard Wright is driven from the band by Waters after having written several of the more inspired moments on their biggest album, Dark Side of the Moon. Of course, by then, you're wondering why he'd even want to stay.

 

 

A super fan would say you'd want to stay around and deal with Waters' bullshit for the glory of the music. But a super fan would more than likely have a bone or two to pick with Blake, who isn't shy about dismissing songs he doesn't like. But he's rarely as cutting as the old reviews he quotes. An early San Francisco gig with Barrett at the helm is written off by Rolling Stone as "simply dull in a dance hall following Big Brother and Janis Joplin," while New Musical Express insisted Dark Side of the Moon was "sometimes positively numbskull." That's when Blake is at his best, providing those details that leap off the page while placing Pink Floyd squarely in the context of the times - like Alan Parsons' 35-pounds-a-week salary for engineering Dark Side of the Moon. A. WATT

 


Mar 10
Jack Bruce: Composing Himself by Harry Shapiro
03/12/2010
Sinner Takes All: A Memoir of Love and Porn by Tera Patrick and Carrie Borzillo
03/09/2010
Dance of Days: Two Decades of Punk in the Nation’s Capital by Mark Anderson and Mark Jenkins
03/03/2010
Feb 10
Girl Power: The Nineties Revolution in Music by Marisa Meltzer
02/25/2010
Black Music by LeRoi Jones (Amiri Baraka)
02/22/2010
Jan 10
Bomp! 2 – Born In The Garage by Suzy Shaw & Mike Stax, eds.
01/26/2010
Jerry Lee Lewis: Lost and Found by Joe Bonomo
01/19/2010
Starting Point: 1979-1996 by Hayao Miyazaki
01/04/2010
Dec 09
Led Zeppelin: Shadows Taller Than Our Souls by Charles R. Cross
12/09/2009
Bicycle Diaries by David Byrne
12/03/2009
Nov 09
Trust: Photographs of Jim Marshall by Jim Marshall
11/27/2009
Our Noise: The Story of Merge Records by John Cook with Mac McCaughan & Laura Ballance
11/20/2009
Wire's Pink Flag by Wilson Neate
11/13/2009
Bowie: A Biography by Marc Spitz
11/05/2009
Oct 09
Man of Constant Sorrow: The Life and Times of a Music Legend by Dr. Ralph Stanley with Eddie Dean
10/27/2009
Juliet, Naked by Nick Hornby
10/22/2009
Sep 09
Will Work for Drugs by Lydia Lunch
09/30/2009
The Rough Guide to Nirvana by Gillian G. Gaar
09/23/2009
Lowside of the Road: A Life of Tom Waits by Barney Hoskyns
09/18/2009
Poisoned Heart: A Punk Love Story by Vera Ramone King
09/07/2009
Aug 09
The Portable February by David Berman
08/19/2009
Kill The Music by Michael G. Plumides, Jr.
08/17/2009
Michael Jackson: Unmasked + The Magic, The Madness, The Whole Story by Ian Halperin + J. Randy Taraborrelli
08/12/2009
The Road to Woodstock + Woodstock Revisited by Michael Lang w/Holly George-Warren + Susan Reynolds (ed.)
08/06/2009
Jul 09
The England's Dreaming Tapes by Jon Savage
07/29/2009
No Certainty Attached: Steve Kilbey and The Church by Robert Dean Lurie
07/29/2009
Family: Photographs by Lauren Dukoff by Lauren Dukoff (foreword by Devendra Banhart)
07/21/2009
Jun 09
Radio City by Bruce Eaton
06/30/2009
Cat Power: A Good Woman by Elizabeth Goodman
06/23/2009
No Depression: Instruments Of Change by Grant Alden & Peter Blackstock (Editors)
06/17/2009
Waiting For The Sun by Barney Hoskyns
06/12/2009
Please Step Back by Ben Greenman
06/09/2009
May 09
The Song Is You by Arthur Phillips
05/07/2009
Apr 09
Bill Bruford: The Autobiography by Bill Bruford
04/24/2009
Infinity Blues by Ryan Adams
04/17/2009
The Hip Hop Wars by Tricia Rose
04/09/2009
Mar 09
Songs From A Dutch Tour by Chip Taylor
03/13/2009
It Shined: The Saga of The Ozark Mountain Daredevils by Mike "Supe" Granda
03/10/2009
The 100 Greatest Metal Guitarists by Joel McIver
03/03/2009
Feb 09
1 of 1500: A Ten-Year Poster Retrospective by Higher Ground, Iskra Print Collective & JDK Design
02/25/2009
Notable Moments of Women in Music by Jay Warner
02/12/2009
I Hate New Music by Dave Thompson
02/09/2009
Jan 09
The Album Cover Album by Storm Thorgerson & Roger Dean
01/27/2009
Jeffrey T. Roesgen by Rum, Sodomy & The Lash
01/16/2009
Dec 08
When I Grow Up by Juliana Hatfield
12/03/2008
Nov 08
Sing Me Back Home by Dana Jennings
11/26/2008
Hot Burritos: The True Story of the Flying Burrito Brothers by John Einarson with Chris Hillman
11/14/2008
No Depression 76 by Grant Alden and Peter Blackstock, eds.
11/06/2008
Oct 08
Old Rare New: The Independent Record Shop by Emma Pettit & Nadine Käthe Monem, eds.
10/31/2008
Sep 08
Goodbye 20th Century + Psychic Confusion by David Browne + Stevie Chick
09/12/2008
I Have Fun Everywhere I Go by Mike Edison
09/03/2008
Aug 08
No Wave: Post-Punk. Underground. New York. 1976-1980. by Thurston Moore and Byron Coley
08/27/2008
The Adventures of Grandmaster Flash: My Life, My Beats by Grandmaster Flash and David Ritz
08/25/2008
Making Notes by Ann Wicker (ed.)
08/20/2008
Throbbing Gristle - 20 Jazz Funk Greats by Drew Daniel
08/13/2008
No Wave + New York Noise by Marc Masters + Stuart Baker/Paula Court
08/01/2008
Jul 08
Lady Lazarus by Andrew Foster Altschul
07/23/2008
Horses by Philip Shaw
07/02/2008
Jun 08
Riot Grrrl: Revolution Girl Style Now! by Nadine Monem (ed.)
06/23/2008
Pretty Vacant: A History of UK Punk by Phil Strongman
06/16/2008
Bowie In Berlin by Thomas Jerome Seabrook
06/10/2008
Northline by Willy Vlautin
06/10/2008
The Source: The Untold Story of Father Yod, Yahowa 13 and the Source Family by Isis Aquarian with Electricity Aquarian
06/09/2008
Wax Poetics Anthology Volume 1 by Wax Poetics Anthology Volume 1
06/09/2008
CREEM: American's Only Rock 'n' Roll Magazine by Robert Matheu and Brian J. Bowe (eds.)
06/09/2008